While outstanding customer service is a key ingredient in any business, there are some industries where the stakes are especially high—and insurance is a prime example. The insurance sector deals with matters that directly impact people's lives, financial security, and peace of mind, making exceptional customer service not just desirable but essential.
In the insurance industry, not only must customer support agents in the contact center provide professional, friendly, and timely service, they must also be proficient at dealing with the complexities of high-value claims processes, all while being aware of potentially fraudulent activities. This dual responsibility of delivering empathetic service while maintaining vigilance makes the role particularly challenging and crucial for business success.
The impact of customer service on success in the insurance industry cannot be understated, especially considering:
- Satisfied customers are 80% more likely to renew their insurance policies than dissatisfied customers.
- CX leaders in the insurance industry demonstrate higher revenue growth, lower expense ratios, and higher employee satisfaction scores.
- 83% of insurance customers who are dissatisfied with the way a claim was handled say they are planning to switch or have already switched to another provider.
In this article, we'll outline five insurance customer service best practices that can help you deliver outstanding support in your contact center, ensuring that your customers stick around for the long term and boosting customer retention.
1. Ensure your agents care about high-quality service
While technology, tools, and processes all play a central role in delivering an outstanding service in the insurance sector, customer support is ultimately about people. Without the right customer service agents, you'll struggle to deliver a service that meets your customers' expectations. The human element remains irreplaceable, especially in an industry where customers often reach out during stressful or challenging situations.
Customer support agents are a key link between your customer base and your business. In your customers' eyes, they are your business — and the service they receive will have a direct impact on their opinion of your company as a whole. These frontline representatives shape customer perceptions, build trust, and maintain relationships that can last for decades. Their ability to handle complex situations with empathy and professionalism can transform challenging interactions into opportunities for strengthening customer loyalty.
Hiring the right contact center agents is a critical first step in ensuring high-quality service for your insurance customers, leading to several significant benefits:
- Improved customer satisfaction through consistent, knowledgeable, and empathetic service delivery
- More loyal customers and higher retention rates, resulting in increased lifetime customer value
- A reputation as an insurance company that puts customers first, leading to positive word-of-mouth and organic growth
Effective recruitment often requires a good deal of time, resources, and money, but it's a step you simply cannot afford to cut corners on. While this is true regardless of the industry you operate in, it is particularly important in an industry as complex and high-value as insurance. The cost of poor hiring decisions can be substantial, both in terms of customer satisfaction and operational efficiency.
2. Provide comprehensive training
If hiring the right agents is the first critical step, supporting them through comprehensive insurance training is the second. Without the latter, you'll undo all your hard work in the former. Even the most talented and motivated agents need thorough training to navigate the complexities of insurance products and services effectively.
With the average insurance contact center experiencing agent turnover rates of 30-45%, onboarding and upskilling new agents is a constant challenge. With complex and detailed insurance processes, training new agents to the point where they can confidently and accurately deal with customer interactions can take weeks or even months, leading to resource challenges and reduced performance across the contact center. This makes it essential to have a well-structured, efficient training program that can quickly bring new agents up to speed.
Effective onboarding and training should equip insurance contact center agents with the ability to:
- Handle industry, policy, claims and company-specific queries, ensuring they have the knowledge to answer customer questions and solve issues confidently and accurately
- Navigate the complexities of the insurance industry confidently, understanding both technical details and regulatory requirements
- Be able to navigate internal processes seamlessly even when handling challenging interactions
- Use various tech platforms and tools that work with the agent rather than against them, maximizing productivity and ensuring consistent service delivery
The technical nature of insurance products, combined with the emotional aspects of claims handling, can create a particularly challenging environment for undertrained agents. Without comprehensive training, agents can easily become overwhelmed by the complexities of insurance processes and customer interactions, resulting in poor service quality, increased error rates, and ultimately, dissatisfied customers. From the agents' perspective, being ill-equipped for such a demanding role can be extremely stressful and demotivating, leading to burnout, decreased job satisfaction, and significantly higher turnover rates.
Training shouldn't be viewed merely as a one-off event confined to the initial onboarding process. A holistic approach that balances technical systems and process training with ongoing soft skills coaching and structured career development sessions is essential. Agents will feel more engaged and confident in their roles if they receive continuous guidance and support that is specifically tailored to their individual needs and growth areas, allowing them to systematically close skills gaps and improve on identified areas for development.
This comprehensive approach to training is particularly crucial in the insurance industry, where strict adherence to regulatory compliance and effective risk management is non-negotiable, but simultaneously, maintaining engaged and motivated contact center agents is a fundamental factor in driving business success and delivering exceptional customer experiences.
Key skills to focus on in insurance customer service training:
- Empathy and active listening: Teaching agents to understand and respond appropriately to customers' emotional states, especially during stressful claim situations
- Conflict resolution and managing complaints: Equipping agents with techniques to de-escalate tensions and transform negative experiences into positive outcomes
- Time management and documentation: Training on efficient call handling while maintaining accurate and detailed records of all customer interactions
- Verbal and written communication: Developing clear, professional communication skills across all channels while maintaining a consistent brand voice
- Email etiquette and phone techniques: Mastering professional communication protocols and best practices for different communication channels
- Cross-selling and insurance coverage knowledge: Building comprehensive product knowledge and identifying appropriate opportunities for additional coverage
- Fraud prevention and ethical conduct: Understanding red flags, following verification protocols, and maintaining ethical standards
- Cultural sensitivity and customer education: Developing awareness of diverse customer needs and effectively explaining complex insurance concepts
Technology can play a key role here—not only in delivering training activities but also in providing real-time support to agents during customer interactions. Take dynamic scripting software, for example—a technology that intelligently guides agents through customer conversations, allowing them to focus on one topic at a time while ensuring compliance and consistency.
Scripting technology serves a dual purpose: it not only enables agents to focus on delivering outstanding service by reducing cognitive load, but it also minimizes the need for extensive formal training sessions. Instead, it functions as an intelligent in-work learning tool that continuously guides agents toward greater proficiency in their role, promoting natural skill development through practical application.
3. Offer omnichannel support
In an increasingly digital world where regulatory compliance and process complexity must be balanced with delivering memorable service experiences, insurance companies that adopt a flexible, efficient, and technology-driven customer-centric approach to service delivery will gain a significant competitive advantage. Omnichannel support is a prime example of this modern approach.
We live in an era of choice, where customers expect to interact with businesses through multiple channels, including:
- Over the phone: Traditional voice support for complex or sensitive issues
- Email: Written communication for detailed queries and documentation
- Live chat via a website: Real-time digital support for quick questions
- Social media and online community platforms: Public and private messaging options
- Self-help support via online forums, videos, etc.: On-demand resources for independent problem-solving
Each communication mode offers distinct advantages and serves different customer preferences. Some customers feel most comfortable with traditional phone conversations, while others prefer the convenience and documentation of written communications. Some may require the immediacy of live chat, while others value the ability to research solutions independently through self-service options. By limiting customer support to a single mode of communication, you risk forcing customers to interact through channels they find confusing, uncomfortable, or in some cases, completely inaccessible.
4. Identify areas of improvement
Understanding performance, checking QA, and identifying areas for improvement is critical to providing a consistently excellent standard of support. The insurance industry has to strike a balance between delivering a good experience, despite the difficult nature of the calls, and aligning to QA expectations and guidance.
Insurance businesses operate in a highly regulated environment with constantly changing rules and guidance. Companies need to provide reassurance not just internally but also to customers and regulators that compliance is being monitored accurately and that immediate action can be taken where needed.
This means that many insurance QA teams spend the majority of their time analyzing calls rather than being able to use their expertise to drive proactive improvements before they become large-scale issues. The good news is that modern technology is now making it easier than ever to assess QA, customer interactions and fine-tune performance metrics.
With the right software, customer support managers and QA teams can ensure that 100% of customer-agent interactions are monitored and analyzed, guiding better outcomes with the following functionality:
- Contact center quality monitoring that provides comprehensive oversight of all interactions, enabling targeted coaching while maintaining consistent service standards across all channels
- Advanced automatic alerts that instantly flag potential compliance breaches or suspicious activities, allowing for immediate response to risk scenarios and maintaining robust fraud prevention protocols
- Sophisticated, user-friendly dashboards that present actionable insights in an easily digestible format, empowering both agents and leadership teams to make informed, data-driven decisions that enhance service delivery and operational efficiency
Through conversation intelligence software powered by advanced AI, insurance customer calls can be automatically transcribed and analyzed with remarkable accuracy. These systems can identify nuanced speech patterns, key discussion topics or behaviors, and even decode the subtle emotional undertones and underlying intent behind the language used by both customers and agents during interactions.
This sophisticated analysis provides contact center managers with comprehensive insights that extend far beyond basic performance metrics. The technology delivers a detailed understanding of customer sentiment trends, agent performance patterns, and even the emotional state of call center staff members. This holistic view enables managers to identify potential burnout situations, recognize stress indicators, and implement supportive measures proactively. Ultimately, this data-driven approach helps to precisely pinpoint areas requiring improvement and enables the delivery of targeted support interventions at the optimal time—benefiting customers and agents alike.
5. Deploy cutting-edge software
Technology is the driving force behind almost all of the best practices we’ve discussed in this article. Modern contact center platforms now offer comprehensive functionality that can dramatically strengthen and enhance your customer service operations. These solutions integrate seamlessly with existing systems, such as CRMs and knowledge bases, while providing the scalability needed for future growth.
However, navigating the increasingly crowded marketplace of technology solutions and software platforms can present a significant challenge for insurance organizations. In an industry characterized by its complexity and unique regulatory requirements, it becomes crucial to partner with a software provider that not only understands these specific challenges but has also developed solutions tailored to address them effectively.
The right software will enhance the customer journey, simplify internal processes, and provide powerful interaction insights, allowing your customer service teams to understand their performance and identify areas for improvement.
Beyond mere technical features, the right software provider should demonstrate a proven track record of success in the insurance industry specifically. They should be able to provide concrete examples of how their solutions have helped other insurance organizations overcome similar challenges and achieve measurable improvements in their customer support operations.
The results achieved by one of our insurance contact center clients serve as a testament to the transformative power of the right technology solution. Using our real-time agent guidance and conversation intelligence software, they experienced significant improvements in customer journey metrics, dramatic reductions in call handling times, and a notable decrease in agent turnover rates. The platform's integrated approach enabled them to upskill agents 70% faster than they could with traditional training methods, as all processes are centralized within the Creovai platform. This streamlined approach allows new agents to begin handling calls effectively within days rather than weeks, marking a substantial improvement in overall agent productivity.
Take the first step to enhancing insurance customer service
At Creovai, we have established ourselves as trusted partners to numerous high-performance insurance contact centers and customer support teams. Drawing upon decades of collective contact center experience within our team, we've developed our software to be adaptable, powerful, and cost-effective while meeting the specific needs of the insurance industry.
Our AI-powered software streamlines support processes, provides unparalleled insights into performance, and helps you provide a superior experience for both customers and agents alike, with products like:
We also understand the unique challenges that agents in insurance companies face — everything from high-stakes calls about complex insurance products to regulatory compliance and fraud detection. Our deep industry expertise has enabled us to develop a comprehensive system packed with features specifically designed to help insurance providers deliver exceptional support while navigating these intricate demands.
If you’d like to see how Creovai could help enhance your customer service and simplify the insurance claims process, book a demo today.
Whether you're looking to elevate your omnichannel service, improve agent performance, or automate your quality assurance processes, our team of experts is committed to helping you create a more efficient, effective, and customer-focused insurance company.
.png)
